> For the complete documentation index, see [llms.txt](https://docs.shapemaker.io/llms.txt). Markdown versions of documentation pages are available by appending `.md` to page URLs; this page is available as [Markdown](https://docs.shapemaker.io/technical-details/buckling-length-assessment-with-lba-method.md).

# Buckling length assessment with LBA method

## Linear buckling analysis (LBA) in Shapemaker

### What is it used for

LBA (linear buckling analysis) gives every compressed member of a 3D frame structure its buckling length $$L\_{cr}$$. The buckling resistance check of EN 1993-1-1, clause 6.3.1, uses that length.

A member in compression can stop carrying load before the steel yields. It bends sideways instead, which is called buckling. The force at which this happens depends on how the member is supported at its ends and along its length.

In the textbook approach, the engineer assumes an effective length factor $$k$$: $$1.0$$ for a pinned member, $$0.7$$ for a member fixed at one end and pinned at the other, $$2.0$$ for a cantilever. In a 3D frame, the supports of a member can be other members. They bend and carry compression themselves, so the right $$k$$ is not obvious. The program derives it from a model of the whole frame.

The buckling length enters the 6.3.1 check through the critical force $$N\_{cr}$$ and the relative slenderness $$\bar{\lambda}$$ (the code's slenderness symbol, unrelated to the multiplier $$\alpha$$ described below):

<p align="center"><span class="math">N_{cr} = \frac{\pi^2 E I}{L_{cr}^2}, \qquad \bar{\lambda} = \sqrt{\frac{A f_y}{N_{cr}}}</span></p>

The slenderness gives the buckling reduction factor $$\chi$$ and the resistance $$N\_{b,Rd} = \chi \cdot A \cdot f\_y / \gamma\_{M1}$$. A longer $$L\_{cr}$$ gives a lower $$N\_{cr}$$, a higher slenderness, and a lower resistance.

### The theory

A member loses stability when the energy needed to bend it equals the work the compressive force does during that bending.

Picture a ruler standing upright while you press down on its top. Under a light push, a sideways nudge makes it spring back. The harder you press, the weaker it springs back. At a certain force, it stops springing back and swings out sideways. That force is the critical force $$N\_{cr}$$.

<figure><img src="https://451777108-files.gitbook.io/~/files/v0/b/gitbook-x-prod.appspot.com/o/spaces%2F6GQOhDmRM226SOi8J4Pp%2Fuploads%2Ftyjqql2E8CuwxddnvMn9%2FUntitled%20(14).svg?alt=media&amp;token=92b8b3d0-98b2-44a6-8f7f-c3552816d090" alt="" width="375"><figcaption></figcaption></figure>

For any bent shape, you can compute two numbers:

* **Bending cost** $$U$$**:** the elastic energy needed to bend the member into that shape; it depends on the bending stiffness $$EI$$ and on the curvature.
* **Load gain** $$W$$**:** a bent member is shorter in height, so its top drops by $$\Delta$$, and the compressive force $$N$$ does the work $$W = N \cdot \Delta$$.

<figure><img src="https://451777108-files.gitbook.io/~/files/v0/b/gitbook-x-prod.appspot.com/o/spaces%2F6GQOhDmRM226SOi8J4Pp%2Fuploads%2FdyI50Amd0ppJrZhrIreg%2FScreenshot%202026-11-05%20130049.png?alt=media&amp;token=c555a9a9-23d2-4493-be18-3bdc2d6d541f" alt=""><figcaption></figcaption></figure>

When $$U > W$$, the member returns to straight. When $$W > U$$, bending “pays off” and the member buckles. The limit is $$U = W$$, so:

<p align="center"><span class="math">N_{cr} = \frac{U}{\Delta}</span></p>

Both numbers grow with the square of the deflection, so $$N\_{cr}$$ does not depend on how far we bend the member. It depends only on the shape, the stiffness, and the length.

There are many buckling modes: a single bow, an S-shape, only the lower part bending, or only the upper part. Each has its own critical force. The one that gives way first is the one that matters.

The critical buckling load multiplier says how many times the actual compression $$N\_{Ed}$$ must grow for the member to buckle. Each mode has its own multiplier $$\alpha\_i$$. The multiplier of the mode the program takes a span's length from is written $$\alpha\_{cr}$$ (EN 1993-1-1, 5.2.2), and the critical force is $$N\_{cr} = \alpha\_{cr} \cdot N\_{Ed}$$. Finally, the critical force is turned into the length of a pinned member that would buckle at the same force:

<p align="center"><span class="math">L_{cr} = \pi \sqrt{\frac{E I}{N_{cr}}}</span></p>

### How the program runs LBA

The program makes the same cost-against-gain comparison, but for the whole frame at once and without guessing the shape. LBA runs inside the structure analysis, after the static analysis and before the member checks.

* **Frame model:** Each member is split into short beam elements, no longer than 0.1 m and at least 4 per member. Supports, member end releases, and drawn restraints act as conditions on how the nodes may move. Angles are analysed twice: on their principal axes for the length about the weak axis v, and on their geometric axes for the lengths about y and z.

<figure><img src="https://451777108-files.gitbook.io/~/files/v0/b/gitbook-x-prod.appspot.com/o/spaces%2F6GQOhDmRM226SOi8J4Pp%2Fuploads%2FBgQ58jwjPqqePuD3Xj0w%2FUntitled%20(3).svg?alt=media&amp;token=84d4ef57-c996-47db-a4e5-98d7d38821b2" alt=""><figcaption></figcaption></figure>

* **Forces from the static analysis:** For each ULS combination, the program takes the axial force $$N\_{Ed}$$ in every element. Tension is ignored because it does not cause buckling.

<figure><img src="https://451777108-files.gitbook.io/~/files/v0/b/gitbook-x-prod.appspot.com/o/spaces%2F6GQOhDmRM226SOi8J4Pp%2Fuploads%2FXtNIEyWbIE66C4yVTiAh%2FUntitled%20(4).svg?alt=media&amp;token=ae2cb414-5d80-4932-a95a-98b0e6182a78" alt=""><figcaption></figcaption></figure>

* **Has the frame already buckled:** The program checks the frame under the actual forces of each combination. If the bending cost already loses to the load gain there, the frame is unstable under that combination, and the combination gives no buckling length. If this happens in every combination that compresses the member, the program has no mode to read. Each span then gets its own length (twice the span at a free end), and the results mark it "frame buckled".
* **Which combinations:** A member is analysed in every combination that compresses it to at least 50% of its largest compression, counting only combinations under which the frame is still stable. The longest length found is kept, which is the safe side.
* **Points that hold the member:** Along the member, the program looks for places that stop it moving sideways: supports, drawn restraints, and connections to other members. A connection counts only if it is stiff enough: at least $$\frac{2}{0.75} \frac{2\pi^2 EI}{L\_b^3}$$, where $$L\_b$$ is the longer of the two spans the connection creates (nodal bracing per AISC 360-16, Appendix 6). These points split the member into spans, separately for each direction.

<figure><img src="https://451777108-files.gitbook.io/~/files/v0/b/gitbook-x-prod.appspot.com/o/spaces%2F6GQOhDmRM226SOi8J4Pp%2Fuploads%2FeB9QmnDBO2kFo7vBXvFj%2FUntitled%20(5).svg?alt=media&amp;token=d2c1f7be-5f4b-48cd-90ea-a917563bb54c" alt=""><figcaption></figcaption></figure>

* **What is increased:** The compression of the member being checked, and of the members continuing it in line (one physical column), is multiplied by $$\alpha$$. All other members stay at their actual compression forces. A heavily compressed neighbour then holds the member less, as it does in reality.
* **Buckling modes:** For each element, the program sets up the bending cost (stiffness matrix $$K$$) and the axial-force gain (geometric matrix $$K\_g$$). The eigen problem $$(K + K\_{g,\text{fixed}} + \alpha \cdot K\_{g,\text{increased}}) \phi = 0$$ gives up to 24 modes $$\phi\_i$$, each with its own multiplier $$\alpha\_i$$, from the lowest.

<figure><img src="https://451777108-files.gitbook.io/~/files/v0/b/gitbook-x-prod.appspot.com/o/spaces%2F6GQOhDmRM226SOi8J4Pp%2Fuploads%2Ft50DLCZ62tXKeqlMHEJM%2FUntitled%20(6).svg?alt=media&amp;token=50a4d9c9-d803-4521-8274-1c8e54e03f7c" alt=""><figcaption></figcaption></figure>

* **Which mode belongs to which span:** A span takes the lowest mode in which it genuinely bends: it holds at least 50% of the strain energy of the most strained span of the whole column (the member together with its collinear members). A column drawn as one member or as several therefore gets the same lengths. A span that is only carried along by a neighbour is not read in that mode. If no mode belongs to a span, the program solves it separately, with only its own compression increased.
* **Buckling length:** $$N\_{cr} = \alpha\_{cr} \cdot N\_{Ed}$$, where $$\alpha\_{cr}$$ is the multiplier of the mode assigned to the span and $$N\_{Ed}$$ is the largest compression in the span (EN 1993-1-1, 5.2.2(8)). Then $$L\_{cr} = \pi \sqrt{EI / N\_{cr}}$$. The result is never shorter than the span itself (twice the span at a free end) and never longer than the length from the lowest mode of the whole member.

<figure><img src="https://451777108-files.gitbook.io/~/files/v0/b/gitbook-x-prod.appspot.com/o/spaces%2F6GQOhDmRM226SOi8J4Pp%2Fuploads%2Fq67teqySr7Wc6CBKa8Al%2FUntitled%20(7).svg?alt=media&amp;token=6adcf972-bad5-47c8-aa17-f5cf699d7985" alt=""><figcaption></figcaption></figure>

* **Which combinations:** A member is analysed in every combination that compresses it to at least 50% of its largest compression. The longest length found is kept, which is the safe side.
* **The engineer's values:** On the member card, you can enter your own $$k$$ ($$L\_{cr} = k \cdot L\_{span}$$) or $$L\_{cr}$$ for any span. That value replaces the analysis result.

The lengths are written onto the member segments in the FE model and from there go to the 6.3.1 check, separately about the y and z axes (and v for angles). In the Results tab, type “Buckling modes” to see the length and $$k$$ of every span and the mode it comes from.

### Worked example: a 1.0 m long pinned bar

A 1.0 m long CHS 88.9×5 tube, pinned at both ends and compressed by 50 kN, buckles at 2412 kN. The critical multiplier is 48.2 and the buckling length is 1.0 m ($$k = 1.0$$). We first work it out by hand with the cost-against-gain method, then compare with the program.

#### Input

| Quantity                          | Symbol                                                | Value                                                |
| --------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------- |
| Member length                     | $$L$$                                                 | $$1000 \text{ mm}$$                                  |
| Section                           |                                                       | CHS 88.9×5, steel S235                               |
| Elastic modulus                   | $$E$$                                                 | $$210 \text{ GPa}$$                                  |
| Second moment of area             | $$I = \frac{\pi}{64} (88.9^4 - 78.9^4) \text{ mm}^4$$ | $$116.4 \text{ cm}^4$$                               |
| Bending stiffness                 | $$EI$$                                                | $$244.4 \text{ kNm}^2$$                              |
| Compression from combination      | $$N\_{Ed}$$                                           | $$50 \text{ kN}$$                                    |
| Largest deflection in calculation | $$a$$                                                 | $$10 \text{ mm}$$ (any value, doesn't change result) |

#### Step 1: the bent shape

We work in relative height $$t = x / L$$, from 0 at the bottom to 1 at the top. The pins stop the ends from moving sideways ($$f = 0$$) and carry no moment ($$f'' = 0$$). The simplest polynomial that satisfies this is:

$$
f(t) = t - 2t^3 + t^4, \qquad f\_{max} = f(0.5) = 0.3125
$$

The actual deflection is $$y = s \cdot f(t)$$. The scale $$s = a / f\_{max} = 10 / 0.3125 = 32.0 \text{ mm}$$ makes the middle of the bar move 10 mm sideways.

#### Steps 2–4: how far the top drops

The bent bar keeps its length, so its top end drops. Each small piece tilted by $$y'$$ loses (by Pythagoras) $$\frac{1}{2} (y')^2$$ of its length in height. The drop $$\Delta$$ is the sum of these losses.

| Step                        | Formula                                                                                                         | Value                                                               |
| --------------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| **2. Slope**                | <p><span class="math">f'(t) = 1 - 6t^2 + 4t^3</span>,<br><span class="math">y' = (s / L) \cdot f'(t)</span></p> | at the ends $$y' = \pm 0.032 \text{ } (1.8^\circ)$$                 |
| **3. Slope squared**        | $$(f')^2 = 1 - 12t^2 + 8t^3 + 36t^4 - 48t^5 + 16t^6$$                                                           |                                                                     |
| **3. Sum along the length** | $$I\_1 = \int\_0^1 (f')^2 dt$$, each $$t^n$$ gives $$\frac{1}{n + 1}$$                                          | $$1 - 4 + 2 + 7.2 - 8 + 2.286 = 17/35 = 0.4857$$                    |
| **4. Drop**                 | $$\Delta = \frac{1}{2} s^2 I\_1 / L$$                                                                           | $$\frac{1}{2} \cdot 32.0^2 \cdot 0.4857 / 1000 = 0.249 \text{ mm}$$ |

#### Steps 5–6: the bending cost

The elastic energy depends on the curvature of the bar, the second derivative of the shape.

| Step                        | Formula                                                                                                           | Value                                                                                                             |
| --------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| **5. Curvature**            | <p><span class="math">f''(t) = -12t + 12t^2</span>,<br><span class="math">y'' = (s / L^2) \cdot f''(t)</span></p> |                                                                                                                   |
| **5. Sum along the length** | $$I\_2 = \int\_0^1 (f'')^2 dt = \int\_0^1 (144t^2 - 288t^3 + 144t^4) dt$$                                         | $$48 - 72 + 28.8 = 4.8$$                                                                                          |
| **6. Bending cost**         | $$U = \frac{1}{2} EI \cdot s^2 \cdot I\_2 / L^3$$                                                                 | $$\frac{1}{2} \cdot 244400 \text{ Nm}^2 \cdot (0.032 \text{ m})^2 \cdot 4.8 / (1 \text{ m})^3 = 600.6 \text{ J}$$ |

#### Steps 7–9: critical force, multiplier and length

| Step                       | Formula                                                 | Value                                                                                 |
| -------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| **7. Critical force**      | $$N\_{cr} = U / \Delta = (I\_2 / I\_1) \cdot EI / L^2$$ | $$600.6 \text{ J} / 0.000249 \text{ m} = 9.88 \cdot 244.4 / 1.0^2 = 2415 \text{ kN}$$ |
| **8. Critical multiplier** | $$\alpha\_{cr} = N\_{cr} / N\_{Ed}$$                    | $$2415 / 50 = 48.3$$                                                                  |
| **9. Buckling length**     | $$L\_{cr} = \pi \sqrt{EI / N\_{cr}}$$                   | $$\pi \sqrt{244.4 / 2415} = 0.999 \text{ m}$$                                         |
|                            | $$k = L\_{cr} / L$$                                     | $$1.00$$                                                                              |

The exact Euler result is $$N\_{cr} = \pi^2 EI / L^2 = 2412 \text{ kN}$$. The assumed polynomial gave $$2415 \text{ kN}$$, 0.13% too high. An approximate shape always comes out slightly too stiff, because the true shape (a sine) is the one that gives the lowest force.

#### How the program computes the same thing

The program does not assume a shape. It splits the bar into 10 elements of 0.1 m. For each one, it sets up the bending cost (matrix $$K$$) and the gain from the 50 kN force (matrix $$K\_g$$), and the eigenproblem finds the shape with the lowest ratio of cost to gain.

| Quantity                                                    | By hand (polynomial) | Program (10 elements) | Exact (Euler)       |
| ----------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------- | --------------------- | ------------------- |
| **Critical multiplier** $$\alpha\_{cr}$$                    | $$48.3$$             | $$48.240$$            | $$48.240$$          |
| **Critical force** $$N\_{cr} = \alpha\_{cr} \cdot N\_{Ed}$$ | $$2415 \text{ kN}$$  | $$2412 \text{ kN}$$   | $$2412 \text{ kN}$$ |
| **Buckling length** $$L\_{cr}$$                             | $$0.999 \text{ m}$$  | $$1.000 \text{ m}$$   | $$1.000 \text{ m}$$ |
| **Factor** $$k$$                                            | $$1.00$$             | $$1.00$$              | $$1.00$$            |

The 6.3.1 check then computes the relative slenderness $$\bar{\lambda} = \sqrt{A \cdot f\_y / N\_{cr}} = \sqrt{13.18 \text{ cm}^2 \cdot 235 \text{ MPa} / 2412 \text{ kN}} = 0.36$$, and from it $$\chi$$ and the resistance $$N\_{b,Rd}$$.

### Other end conditions

The same 1 m tube at 50 kN: the more fixity at the ends, the shorter the buckling length, from 2.0 m for a cantilever down to 0.5 m for a bar fixed at both ends. The procedure stays the same; only the shape $$f(t)$$ changes, because it must satisfy the support conditions.

| End condition | What it blocks                 | Condition on the shape                 |
| ------------- | ------------------------------ | -------------------------------------- |
| **pin**       | sideways movement              | $$f = 0$$ (and $$f'' = 0$$, no moment) |
| **fixed**     | sideways movement and rotation | $$f = 0$$ and $$f' = 0$$               |
| **free end**  | nothing                        | none ($$f'' = 0$$, no moment)          |

*The conditions on* $$f''$$ *are optional, but with them the shape is closer to the true one.*

|                                                        | Pinned–pinned                             | Fixed–pinned                               | Fixed–fixed                                | Cantilever (fixed at bottom)                  |
| ------------------------------------------------------ | ----------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------ | --------------------------------------------- |
| **Shape** $$f(t)$$                                     | $$t - 2t^3 + t^4$$                        | $$3t^2 - 5t^3 + 2t^4$$                     | $$t^2 - 2t^3 + t^4$$                       | $$6t^2 - 4t^3 + t^4$$                         |
| $$f\_{max}$$                                           | $$0.3125$$                                | $$0.260$$                                  | $$0.0625$$                                 | $$3.0$$ (at the top)                          |
| **Scale** $$s = a / f\_{max}$$                         | $$32.0 \text{ mm}$$                       | $$38.5 \text{ mm}$$                        | $$160 \text{ mm}$$                         | $$3.33 \text{ mm}$$                           |
| $$I\_1 = \int (f')^2 dt$$                              | $$17/35 = 0.486$$                         | $$12/35 = 0.343$$                          | $$2/105 = 0.019$$                          | $$72/7 = 10.29$$                              |
| **Drop** $$\Delta = \frac{1}{2} s^2 I\_1 / L$$         | $$0.249 \text{ mm}$$                      | $$0.254 \text{ mm}$$                       | $$0.244 \text{ mm}$$                       | $$0.057 \text{ mm}$$                          |
| $$I\_2 = \int (f'')^2 dt$$                             | $$24/5 = 4.8$$                            | $$36/5 = 7.2$$                             | $$4/5 = 0.8$$                              | $$144/5 = 28.8$$                              |
| **Cost** $$U = \frac{1}{2} EI s^2 I\_2 / L^3$$         | $$601 \text{ J}$$                         | $$1302 \text{ J}$$                         | $$2503 \text{ J}$$                         | $$39 \text{ J}$$                              |
| $$N\_{cr} = (I\_2 / I\_1) \cdot EI / L^2$$             | $$9.88 \cdot EI / L^2 = 2415 \text{ kN}$$ | $$21.0 \cdot EI / L^2 = 5132 \text{ kN}$$  | $$42.0 \cdot EI / L^2 = 10264 \text{ kN}$$ | $$2.80 \cdot EI / L^2 = 684 \text{ kN}$$      |
| $$N\_{cr}$$ **exact**                                  | $$\pi^2 EI / L^2 = 2412 \text{ kN}$$      | $$20.19 \cdot EI / L^2 = 4934 \text{ kN}$$ | $$4\pi^2 EI / L^2 = 9648 \text{ kN}$$      | $$\frac{\pi^2}{4} EI / L^2 = 603 \text{ kN}$$ |
| **Error of assumed shape**                             | $$+0.1%$$                                 | $$+4.0%$$                                  | $$+6.4%$$                                  | $$+13.5%$$                                    |
| $$\alpha\_{cr} = N\_{cr} / 50 \text{ kN}$$ **(exact)** | $$48.2$$                                  | $$98.7$$                                   | $$193.0$$                                  | $$12.1$$                                      |
| $$L\_{cr}$$ **exact**                                  | $$1.00 \text{ m}$$                        | $$0.70 \text{ m}$$                         | $$0.50 \text{ m}$$                         | $$2.00 \text{ m}$$                            |

A cantilever does not have to bend much for its top to swing out, so the cost is small and so is the critical force. With fixed ends, the bar must leave its supports straight and bend more sharply, so the cost rises while the drop barely changes. The program searches for the shape instead of assuming it, so it does not carry this error: for pinned–pinned it gives the Euler result (see the comparison in the example above).

### Assumptions and limitations

LBA gives the critical force of an ideal elastic member, not its resistance. Imperfections and plasticity come in only through the reduction factor $$\chi$$ in the 6.3.1 check.

* **Elastic material and small deflections.** The geometry before buckling is the undeformed geometry. The frame model includes the members' axial stiffness, so a brace that stretches holds the member less. The hand method above assumes the member keeps its length, which is accurate enough for a single bar.
* **Flexural buckling only.** Torsion and lateral-torsional buckling are not part of the LBA. Fibre ties ($$y+$$, $$y-$$, $$z+$$, $$z-$$) on restraints are stored for a future lateral-torsional check.
* **Drawn restraints are rigid** and the static analysis does not see them. They suit an element much stiffer than the member that carries almost no load.
* **A lightly compressed span gets a long** $$L\_{cr}$$**.** Because $$N\_{cr} = \alpha\_{cr} \cdot N\_{Ed}$$, with a small $$N\_{Ed}$$ (self-weight only, for example), the critical force comes out small and the length long. The effect on utilisation is then small, because $$N\_{Ed}$$ is small.

### When a result looks doubtful

If you are not sure the buckling length from LBA is right, enter it by hand based on engineering judgement. On the member card, in the buckling length table, you can set a factor $$k$$ or a length $$L\_{cr}$$ for each span and each axis. That value replaces the analysis result in the 6.3.1 check.
